V. The
Teleological Principle
(Teleology comes from
the Greek "telos" which means "purpose." It
is the theory that natural phenomena are driven by laws that guide
them toward certain goals of self-realization.)
Teleology
in physics
The study of
teleology began in Greece during the sixth century BC. It was based
on the minimal principle, which was thought to govern the
behavior of physical systems from beginning to end by minimizing
a certain quantity. Hero of Alexandria was the first to give a teleological
meaning to the idea of the minimal principle in the first century
AD. He showed that if light goes from a source to a mirror and from
the mirror to a person's eye, the path taken is the shortest and
thus takes the least time. Hero asserted that this behavior is teleological
because it is determined by the final destination, the eye.
The
study was abandoned until the 17th century when Pierre de Fermat,
a French lawyer who had studied mathematics, applied the principle
to the behavior of light in both reflection and refraction. (Reflection
is the throwing back of rays of light, sound, and heat by a surface
such as a mirror; refraction is the bending of rays as
they pass at an angle from a substance of one density - thickness
- to another of a different density, or from layers of different
density in the same substance. For instance, light is bent when
it passes from air to water.)
Fermat
showed that it could be understood if one assumed that it travels
from one point to another in the least amount of time. Fermat's
principle of least time for reflection was the same as Hero's minimal
principle. Concerning refraction, however, Fermat was able to correctly
predict its behavior two hundred years before it was proven by experiments.
This was the first time that behavior in physics had been correctly
predicted based solely on teleological premises.
Less
than one hundred years later, building on Fermat's work, the
French mathematician Pierre L. M. De Maupertuis reformulated
the laws of physics in terms of the principle of least action,
stating that physical laws indicated the
teleological
influence of Nature. Not long after,
the principle of least action was made more general by the French
mathematician Leonhard Euler who turned it into a theorem.
(A theorem is
an idea that can be deduced from accepted premises.)
In
the 1700s, matter was believed to be made up of particles. Therefore,
building on the model developed by Euler, the French mathematician
Jean L. Lagrange applied the principle
of least action to the dynamics of interacting particles. In the
1850s, however, the Irish mathematician Sir William R. Hamilton
and the German mathematician Karl Gustav Jacobi developed a
model that treated the Universe as composed not of particles but
waves. They thought in terms of a small boat being moved up, down,
and around in the ocean and its motion growing out of the collection
of the movements of all waves. They showed that the presence of
one wave at one particular place is not a single event but the result
of waves coming from all over the ocean. They proposed that all
motion and change in matter are ruled by the principle of least
action and that everything that happens at the physical level is
the expression of a basic unity in Nature. When Hamilton and Jacobi
presented their theory they were not given credence. However, discoveries
in subatomic physics more than fifty years later proved that their
model had been correct.
The
principle of least action was applied in a unique way by the
American
physicist and Nobel Prize winner Richard Feynman. While a
graduate student in the 1940s, Feynman developed with the American
physicist and
Nobel
laureate John A. Wheeler, his teacher at the time, a quantum
theory of electrodynamics (a
model of the behavior of electric currents and associated magnetic
fields)
in which he showed that rays of light emitted by an electrically
charged particle (radiation)
reacting
to another particle could be explained in terms of the interactions
of all particle that occurred in the past and will occur in the
future. In other words, how a
particle radiates today depends on how all particles radiated yesterday
and will radiate tomorrow.
Feyman
diagram
Today,
physical scientists think of the principle of least action as the
law of the whole. This means that a complete understanding
of the behavior of single waves and particles cannot be obtained
independent of the whole; it can only be achieved when waves are
treated as a web of relationships, i.e., as an interaction of parts
forming an inseparable unit. This is, after all, at the core of
the definition of universe. (In
classical physics the parts are seen as forming the whole; in quantum
physics the whole is seen as forming the parts.)
Teleology
in biochemistry
The American biochemist Lawrence J. Henderson was the first
to identify the chemical elements carbon, hydrogen, nitrogen, oxygen,
and water, carbon dioxide and other key molecules as possessing
the unique properties necessary for life. He showed that life would
not have been possible if their properties had been different even
in the smallest degree. He also pointed out that the chance that
these key traits were acquired by accident was so small that it
was less than any probability that could be mathematically considered.
Here are a few important traits:
1.
Carbon is the element whose singular qualities makes it ideally
suited to act as the backbone to countless molecules, including
the molecules of life;
2.
Hydrogen and oxygen combine to from water;
3.
Carbon and oxygen form carbon dioxide. Plants need carbon dioxide
in photosynthesis, a process by which plants, with the help of light,
turn carbon dioxide and water into organic substances. Carbon dioxide
also plays a crucial role in the regulation of the temperature of
the Earth's surface;
4.
Hydrogen, oxygen, and nitrogen are uniquely suited to participate
in the formation of the molecules of life;
5.
Nitrogen and hydrogen combine to form ammonia, a source of nitrogen
on which living organisms depend;
6.
Oxygen in a different form is ozone. A thin layer of ozone surrounds
the planet and controls the amount of ultraviolet rays that enter
the atmosphere.
Later,
sulfur and phosphorous were added to the above four elements because
they play key roles in the transfer of energy in chemical reactions.
Other unique elements are sodium and potassium which help regulate
biochemical reactions; iron because it is the main atom in hemoglobin,
the molecule that carries oxygen from the lungs to the tissues and
carbon dioxide from the tissues to the lungs; and magnesium, the
key atom in chlorophyll thought by scientists to be the perfect
molecule for photosynthesis because it is receptive to light and
has an inert structure that allows it to store energy and transfer
it to other molecules.
The behavior of physical,
chemical, and biological systems is purposeful. Recent discoveries
show that the final goal of biological evolution is the development
of human beings.